The Indianapolis Colts’ 2024 season took another downward turn following a demoralizing Week 17 loss to the New York Giants, officially ending their playoff hopes. The defeat has intensified criticism of head coach Shane Steichen and reignited questions about the team’s culture, leadership, and direction.
The Colts’ season has been marred by inconsistency and internal turmoil. Following the controversial benching of quarterback Anthony Richardson, several players, including team captains, publicly criticized the team’s approach. Kenny Moore II called out the lack of effort and urgency, saying, “I don’t think the urgency is there. I don’t think the details are there.” Similarly, Zaire Franklin and Julian Blackmon voiced concerns about the team’s preparation and commitment.
The growing chorus of criticism has drawn attention to longstanding cultural issues within the organization. Former Colts player and analyst Pat McAfee highlighted these concerns, citing past incidents of unprofessional behavior under previous leadership and arguing that these issues persist.
Despite the mounting concerns, Steichen has denied that the team has a culture problem. Speaking after the loss to The Athletic’s James Boyd, Steichen dismissed the idea, stating, “I think you’re going to go through adversity in seasons… and you got to handle it the best way you can.”
When pressed on the team’s standards, Steichen emphasized preparation, character, and consistency but admitted the failure to reach the playoffs was “disappointing.” The Colts have now missed the postseason for four straight seasons, marking their longest playoff drought in three decades.
The defeat to the Giants and the surrounding controversy have left fans questioning the team’s ability to improve for 2025. With leadership denying systemic problems, the path forward for the Colts remains uncertain, and their extended playoff absence has only deepened frustrations among the fanbase.
One thought on “Colts Face Scrutiny After Crushing Week 17 Loss”